Why Fish Are Good for Your Mystery Novel

Mystery readers love to exercise. Exercise theirand the solution to the case.
minds, that is!For example; my detective knows his quarry
A great mystery should challenge readers andstrolled out of a Super Shoe store at six o'clock
make them think. Readers want to figure out theon the night in question. The pavement in front of
mystery along with the detective and not be ablethe store was freshly cemented and the suspect
to figure out the mystery by page two. In orderleft shoe prints in the wet cement. The detective
to do this, the writer needs to include a literarythinks the size 6 shoe print with the distinctive
device called a red herring.outline of the newest Stuart Wietzman Empire
What is a red herring?boots is the suspects and asks the shoe
A red herring is a dried, smoked herring that lookssaleswomen for a printout of all the women who
red from the curing process.bought that shoe in the last week.
Why should a mystery writer stick kipper snacksHowever, the detective didn't realize the suspect
into their plot line?would NEVER wear a new pair of three hundred
From the information I could find on the original ofdollars boots on wet cement, and had left her
the phrase, it seems some kind-hearted folkstreadless Nike's on! The boots are a red herring.
would try to save a hunted fox by dragging a redThe best mystery writers use red herrings to
herring across the path of a fleeing fox, confusingkeep the detective on his toes and baffle the
the hound dogs and leading them away from thereader. However, the writer must be sure to also
little red fellow. Another mention of red herringsput real clues along with the red herrings. You
comes from a poem written in the 1680's, aroundcould even put the real clues and the red herring
the same time as the first written mention of thein the same scene, and have your reader try to
fox hunting reference.puzzle out which clue is real, and which one is
Like the hounds who are thrown off the trail infishy.
pursuit of a smoked fish instead of a live fox (theRed herrings are an essential part of your
fish probably tastes better anyway), a red herringmystery plot.. Use them judiciously to baffle your
is a clue meant to confuse readers and makereaders and keep them interested!
them take the wrong path away from the truth