The Murder of Alfalfa - Part II

Unfortunately, that kind of luck doesn't lastand was endlessly inventive as an actor.
forever. Carl left the series in 1940, although theAccording to Blake, when Carl wanted to, he
part followed him everywhere he went. He'dcould get it precisely right on the first take.
knock on doors all day long, chasing down actingSo Carl in his mid-20s felt depressed. Back at the
jobs, but the people doing the hiring would justRoach studios, he was the center of attention.
say, "Hey, Alfie, sing off-key for us." It used toAnd now he felt like he was just another
drive him nuts. He always said it's hard for awashed-up has-been, lurking around the fringes of
former child actor to start working again.the business.
He did star in a couple of movies, There's OneHe did the best he could, on his own. He'd
Born Every Minute and The Great Mike. He playedsupplement his income by taking odd jobs like
Billy Wiggs in Mrs. Wiggs Of The Cabbage Patch.bartending. Or as a professional hunting guide in
In the late '40s, he top-lined three low-budget Gasthe High Sierra. Actually, he was pretty good at
House Kids programmers, where he was reunitedthat. He had his own dogs and equipment. And he
with his perpetual Our Gang nemesis, Tommyenjoyed it. Among his regular clients he counted
"Butch" Bond. Tommy was one of his bestRoy Rogers, Henry Fonda and Jimmy Stewart.
friends. He died of heart failure in Northridge inAnd then there was William Wellman. "Wild Bill"
September of 2005 at the age of 79.they called him. A man's man and one of the
Other than those few high points, it was mostlymost colorful directors in Hollywood. His 1927
downhill for Carl over the next decade. He had bitmovie Wings won the first Oscar for Best Picture.
parts in Leo McCarey's Going My Way, in CourageCarl was on a big-game hunting trip with him, but
Of Lassie, A Letter To Three Wives, and theWellman didn't recognize him. He kept glancing at
Tracy-Hepburn vehicle, Pat and Mike. Most of theCarl-- couldn't quite place him, although he thought
time, he didn't even get his name in the credits.he looked familiar. Finally, he said something about
Frank Capra had written a couple of Our Gangit, and Carl reluctantly told him he was Alfalfa.
scripts in the '20s. He cast Carl in two classics.Wellman laughed and said, "You're gonna be in my
First in It's A Wonderful Life in 1946, when Carlnext picture." Carl's eyes bugged out, just like
was 19. He played Donna Reed's boring date atAlfalfa's.
the school dance. It's a good small role. He and hisThe man was as good as his word. Carl Switzer
buddy are the pair who crank open the swimmingwas cast as Hopper in William A. Wellman's Island
pool that Stewart and Reed fall into whileIn The Sky in 1953...and got his name in the
jitterbugging. In the ensuing chaos, Carl shrugs andcredits at the beginning of the movie. And then
joins his classmates in the big splash.the next year, he did another one for Wild Bill. He
And then later he showed up in anotherplayed Ensign Keim in The High And The Mighty. It
Tracy-Hepburn movie, this one for Capra, Statewas a huge box- office smash.
Of The Union, in 1948. But by then the roles wereBoth were John Wayne movies, made by
getting smaller and less frequent. Almost as ifWayne's production company, Batjac. Later the
producers were embarrassed to cast him.same year, they offered Carl more work. It was
Then in the '50s, Our Gang was resurrected onanother Wellman picture, Track Of The Cat,
television as The Little Rascals. It was anstarring Robert Mitchum, from a novel by Walter
enormous thumping success. Alfalfa wasVan Tilburg Clark. Carl was to play Joe Sam, a
rediscovered by a new batch of children, and the100-year-old Piute Indian ranch hand. It was a
character became just as beloved and captivatingchallenge, to put it mildly. He was 26 at the time.
as he was in the '30s.No one alive today can say why on earth they'd
But it was a mixed blessing for Carl Switzer. Itcast a skinny white kid in a part like that, but the
made him happy to feel recognized, but it didn'tcompany did hire a native American coach,
help him get work. It seemed to hurt, in fact. And77-year-old Augie Gomez, a Mohawk and former
while the syndicators of the series were making aextra and stand-in, to help him get the character
fortune--millions upon millions--Alfalfa and the restright. Carl did okay with it, certainly didn't
of the Our Gang stars didn't get a penny. Thereembarrass himself.
was no such thing as residuals in those days.It took three hours to get him into make-up
Carl felt bitter about it, even though he had fondevery day. And he was perfectly happy to sit
memories of his seasons in Our Gang. He andthere while they did it.
Tommy Bond had really hit it off. In the storiesCarl felt like things were looking up. But he was
Butch and Alfalfa were always at each other'sstill the same prankster and trouble-maker. One
throats. But there was no competition betweennight on location he threw a live racoon into
them in real life. They had a lot of laughsMitchum's cabin.
together. They thought of themselves as backlotFive weeks before production, Carl had eloped
kingpins.with Dian Collingwood, the daughter of a wealthy
Carl as a kid was always causing trouble on theKansas farmer. John Wayne's brother, Bob
set. He hated school, and he'd deliberately ruin aMorrison, was best man at the wedding in Las
take with his hi- jinks. Once a cameraman gotVegas. But the couple weren't getting along well.
mad at him and barked at him in annoyance.They broke up during the shoot. Carl was getting
Alfalfa repaid him when everyone was out tohounded by the press. His only comment was, "I
lunch by jamming a mammoth wad of gum insideguess bear hunting and marriage don't mix."
the camera, shutting down production for the restAfter the movie wrapped, Dian told him she was
of the day. Another time, when an impatientexpecting, and they were reconciled. Carl agreed
director was needling him, Carl climbed up on theto get rid of his three hunting dogs. But the
catwalks and took a leak on the hot lights, clearingmarriage didn't last, and they soon divorced.
out the studio because of the rancid smell.Carl soldiered on. He got cast in a semi-recurring
Life was never dull around Alfalfa. Tommy Bondrole on Roy Rogers' TV program. He landed small,
said, "He was a riot. Everybody loved him." Youuncredited parts in a handful of movies, including
never knew what kind of a stunt he'd pull next.Francis In The Navy and The Ten
He was mischievous, and you couldn't control him.Commandments. He was signed to do a comedy
Darla Hood, one of his co-stars, said he waslead in a Huckleberry Finn TV series, but
exciting to be around, but sometimes she wassomehow it never came off.
afraid of him.Then in 1958, he won a juicy featured role in his
Another of his kid co-stars was Robertfinal movie, The Defiant Ones, starring Sidney
Blake--yeah, that Robert Blake, known at thePoitier and Tony Curtis. His part, Angus, ran all the
time by his real name, Mickey Gubitosi. He wasway through the story. Just before it was
impressed with Alfalfa's substantial talents. He hasreleased, Carl told a reporter, "I'll see how this one
said Carl could play several different instrumentsturns out. If this doesn't do it for me, nothing will.